NNN: On Religion, Sexuality, and Masculinity

Recently, Dr. Lindsey Doe released a video on the history, culture and science of semen retention. It was excellent and informative as always. It is also timely-on multiple levels. Firstly, November is a month where semen retention is (in)famously practiced, under the alliterative moniker of “No Nut November”. Secondly, and perhaps more importantly, debates about healthy masculine sexuality and gender expression are becoming increasingly urgent to address as toxic expressions entrench themselves and more healthy expressions struggle to find wide-spread appeal.

While I am no expert in sexology, the intersections of theology and embodiment are right in my area of focus, so I will offer a few thoughts. Two cautions are in order. Firstly, I am not a sexologist or medical expert of any type-if debating the medical and health benefits, consult a licensed physician. Secondly, there may be some discussion about my own sexuality, at least in general terms, so if you’d prefer not to read about that, give this a skip.

Context and Overview: Taoism, Christianity, Modern Debates and Movements

In certain schools of Taoist thought and praxis, semen retention is one of the methods of internal cultivation. The basic idea is that the expulsion of semen depletes essential energies; conservation of semen slows this depletion. Certain additional practices have been developed to convert these conserved energies into a type that allows for greater health (and possibly becoming an Immortal).

In Christianity, passages related to semen retention are mentioned most often in the Pentateuch. The Book of Genesis infamously contains the story of Onan (in relation to the saga of Judah and Tamar). This story was called upon to the extent that some knew masturbation as Onanism. However, this is a poor interpretation. In Genesis 38, a woman Tamar is wed to Judah’s son Er; however, Er dies childless so Onan is commanded to sire a child with Tamar; Onan refuses and “spills his seed upon the ground”, which result in Onan being killed by God as well. Astute readers will note the connection with Deuteronomy 25:5-10 which outlines the procedure for when a husband with brothers dies without a son. While this story has been converted into a condemnation of masturbation, it at most condemns coitus interruptus (a.k.a. the “pull-out method). More accurately, it condemns a violation of the the responsibility to provide for widows and family.

Other verses that relate to semen retention in the Hebrew scriptures include verses about nocturnal emission in the Torah. The emission of semen is indicated as rendering one “unclean”. As many scholars have pointed out, this state of ritual uncleanliness does not have the later connotations of moral sins that Christians later imported. Rather, it is one of several things that are expected to occur in the course of ordinary life. Normally, it doesn’t raise much issue-however, if one wishes to participate in ritual observance, one must become ritually clean through a variety of specified methods.

The New Testament verses commending refraining from marriage and/or sexual relations, both in the sayings of Jesus and the Pauline corpus are also worthy of mention insofar as they say that it is a blessing to those whom it is given not wed or have sexual relations.

So both Taoism and Christianity have traditions which commend either semen retention specifically or sexual abstinence more generally. Judaism, however, tends to be have a more positive view of sexuality, and both Taoism and Christianity fall short of saying that semen retention and sexual abstinence are commanded for all.

In the modern era, several medical practitioners in the 19th and 20th century cautioned against masturbation, attributing to it all manners of ills. However, many of the most vocal voices were tied to Christianity in ways which make their conclusions suspect. As science has progressed, masturbation has become more widely recognized as not harmful, maybe even beneficial. What potential harms there are tend to be in relation to concerns around certain stimuli (i.e. pornography) rather than the act of masturbation itself.

As the Internet and social media accelerated in the first quarter of the twenty-first century, online movements which advocated for semen retention have proliferated. The reasons vary with some being explicitly connected to religious or spiritual concerns and others being related to health and ideas of masculinity more generally; still others are a hodgepodge of both and other sources.

My Reflections

Personally, I remain suspicious of the semen retention movement despite it’s popular adoption among taijiquan practitioners inspired by Taoism and Christians of various backgrounds and beliefs. When I look at the religious/spiritual motivations for semen retention, I must ask whether ancient writers and thinkers interpreted the flood of neurochemicals that led to a period of sleepiness in the immediate aftermath of ejaculation and orgasm as a depletion of vital energies to be avoided without realizing the benefits. Ejaculation and orgasm are associated with a variety of health benefits, some more strongly than others.

Similarly, I question more secular motivations appealing to self-control or neurological resets. Often, I hear in these echoes of Neo-Platonic, dualistic, and Gnostic thought and praxis that concern me. The history of the Western world has attested to the great harm done by privileging the mind over the body and by driving a wedge between the two. Any practices which rely on such divisions I thus treat with great wariness.

I was late to my own practice of solo sex, not beginning until post-secondary school in late adolescence. This is very much related to the fact that I was dyspraxic and had come to view my body as an enemy on many levels. It was only with the appreciation of embodied practices where this division began to be healed. Now, solo sex remains a part of my embodied practice, contributing to my health and well-being.

I will not go so far as to condemn the practice of semen retention altogether. There are those who find it helpful for a time or a season, and evidence for harm from semen retention is uncertain. What I would encourage, however, is for anyone debating whether or not to practice semen retention or sexual abstinence to be honest with themselves (if no one else) as to why they are doing the practice. Is it a short-term break, exercise in self-control and discipline? Is it based in fear, ignorance, or self-hatred? Is it a way to connect more fully with one’s body or is it a way of further alienating oneself from their body?

In May, a similarly alliterative movement known as Masturbation May is the polar opposite of No Nut November, celebrating the benefits of healthy solo sex: being able to explore one’s sexuality, connect with one’s body, monitor a variety of health issues (i.e. issues with solo sex can be signals of things like complications from diabetes or cardiovascular issues), and a host of others. Christianity attests to the “fruits of the Spirit” and taijiquan values several similar virtues-these “fruits” and virtues are associated with many of the health benefits that come from solo sex.

In the end, whether one chooses to practice sex (solo or otherwise) to the point of ejaculation probably matters less than the reasons for doing so. Is it done out of love, for greater connection with your own body and/or the body of another? Or is it done out of fear, ignorance, and self-hatred, to alienate and suppress?

May the questions, and the answers you give, offer insight into the right embodied praxis for you.

Published by Devin Hogg

My name is Devin Hogg. I was born and raised in Carnarvon, Ontario, Canada. I moved to Guelph, Ontario, Canada in 2009 for university and lived here ever since. In my free time, I enjoy reading, watching TV and movies, going on long walks, swimming, and practicing Chen style Tai Chi. I love to write poetry and blog regularly about topics such as mental health, sci-fi/fantasy series, faith, sexuality, and politics.

Leave a Reply